EDITOR’S NOTE: This article was written prior to the San Diego City Council vote on Nov. 16 and has not been altered to reflect subsequent developments. Read alongside the front page for up-to-date information.
San Diego has installed more than 500 Flock Safety cameras since approving them in November 2023. Just off campus in the Linda Vista neighborhood, more than thirteen ALPR cameras have been reported. Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) cameras operate in 49 states, with the most cameras reported in California, followed by Texas and Georgia, according to Map Atlas.
Flock advertises its devices as tools to prevent and monitor crime. The recent influx of Flock cameras has ignited conversations surrounding U.S. citizens’ constitutional rights and mass surveillance.
USD sociology professor Cid Martinez received a doctorate degree from the University of California, Berkeley and was appointed to San Diego’s Privacy Advisory Board in 2022. The Privacy Advisory Board acts as a citizen-led advisory body to the Mayor and City Council on policies and transparency related to the city’s acquisition and use of surveillance technology.
“It’s one thing to have a camera or an officer posted outside of your home, but when you create a network of cameras that have this technology, you’ve gone from observing someone to creating a network in space and time where now… you’re tracking people,” Martinez said.
The Fourth Amendment protects people from unwarranted searches and seizures, and the right to privacy protects individuals from unwarranted intrusion into their personal lives. The cameras reportedly allow police officers and private owners, such as malls and homeowner associations, to see closely into personal parts of people’s lives: where they live, where they go. In Oklahoma, this tracking has the potential to violate an individual’s Fourth Amendment rights, according to United States v. Kyle.
The cameras automatically log the make, model and license plate of every car that passes, also recording the current time. Other identifiers such as bike racks and dents are noted, according to Flock Safety. The cameras record information to build a searchable database of each vehicle’s movement throughout a city. The data is said to potentially reveal private details, including the locations of workplaces, medical offices and homes, according to the American Civil Liberties Union of Oregon.
USD sophomore Emma Carson sees the value in security but worries Flock cameras go too far.
“I think we should have some sort of security system, but I don’t think it should track your every move,” Carson said. “It shouldn’t know everything about you; it shouldn’t know where you live, who you are. I feel like there has to be limits to it.”
Martinez feels similarly and hopes for the enforcement of additional regulations on the devices.
“Right now there’s no state policy so it really depends on how each city provides oversight,” Martinez said. “If we’re going to use this technology, it should be overseen and democratically controlled, and that’s not what was happening in San Diego.”
In 2022, the San Diego City Council approved the Surveillance Oversight Ordinance requiring public disclosure, impact reports and City Council approval for law enforcement surveillance tools. However, in 2024, the City Council voted to roll back major provisions that exempt various police databases and internal monitoring tools from strict oversight. This repealed many of the legal and operational guardrails that were in place to prevent unauthorized use of ALPR surveillance networks.
Public pushback against Flock and other license plate reader cameras is prompting bans in communities nationwide. Santa Cruz became the first California city to cancel its Flock contract in January 2026, and other California cities followed. Similarly, some states have begun to regulate the cameras. This past August, Florida banned ALPR cameras on all state highways and other state-maintained roads. In July 2027, Vermont will become the first state to enact a full statewide ban on all ALPR cameras, while other states such as New Hampshire and Connecticut have strict regulations. New Hampshire mandates the immediate deletion of non-match data, and Connecticut banned the use or sharing of ALPR data for suspected immigration violations or to assist federal immigration enforcement.
“I think Flock cameras are kind of stupid in general because they are doing automated work that should be done by a human,” USD junior Aaron Hernandez said. “Especially the fact that they can mess up.”
In February, a Flock camera in Sherwood, Arkansas, misread the license plate of an SUV, leading officers to detain an innocent couple while their six-week-old baby sat alone in the back of the vehicle. An Institute for Justice review of media reports and court records finds there have been at least 27 similar cases since 2018, with the majority of those happening since 2023.
On Oct. 21, the San Diego City Council’s Budget and Government Efficiency Committee voted to end its contract with Flock Safety. Councilman Stephen Whitburn, who had voted multiple times in favor of the Flock contract and ALPR technology, changed his vote and went against the Flock cameras.
“Until now, I have voted in favor of the cameras as a matter of public safety,” he told San Diego NBC 7. “They have helped solve crimes, and I believe our police department uses them responsibly. The Trump administration and ICE and their un-American, anti-immigrant brutality have created a police state in many of our communities. Many people worry Flock cameras are being used in that crackdown.”
Whitburn’s decision has paved the way for a ban in San Diego. However, ending San Diego’s Flock contract requires a full City Council vote. Without a three-vote majority, Mayor Todd Gloria is likely to veto the resolution.
“Elected leaders shouldn’t be making life easier for criminals,” Gloria told NBC 7 San Diego. “We should be making it easier for our constituents. That’s why I urge the full City Council to preserve this important public safety tool and allow the established oversight process to work.”
San Diego’s fresh look at Flock and ALPR cameras comes as the city fights a lawsuit against the Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans and the American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego. The lawsuit claims that using ALPR surveillance and sharing ALPR data with law enforcement agencies outside California violates the California Constitution. For more information on Flock cameras, visit flocksafety.com.





Join the conversation