“Love Island” and Jane Austen. “Parasite” and Tik Tok. “The Bachelorette” and “The Odyssey.” Colloquially, these art forms exist on virtually opposite sides of a scale that revolve around the idea of “high” and “low” art. One is held in high regard, demonstrated as intellectually stimulating, thought provoking and timeless. The other is often treated as temporary and lucrative entertainment. The origins of high and low art can be traced back to the 18th century Enlightenment period when philosophers became interested in the distinction between art that was made for expression (fine art), and art that was widely available and pragmatic in nature (craft art). As culture has shifted and grown over the last three centuries, the definitions of high and low art have evolved with it. USD English professor Halina Duraj, Ph.D. shared her thoughts on the distinction between the two art forms. “I think of high art as something that has cost the artist a great deal to make, in terms of time, work and attention,” Duraj explained. “[High art] is something that an artist made, in large part for the sake of making it. I thinkof what someone might call low art as something whose purpose in entering the world was primarily, at its inception, about either entertainment or to make a profit, and sometimes the twinning of the two.”
One of the most popular contemporary examples of what many people consider to be low art is reality television. A 2024 Public Broadcast Service (PBS) study found that around 80% of American adults consume reality TV. Many critics of reality TV argue that it is mindless to consume — it lacks authenticity. Proponents of the genre argue that it not only allows for mental escapism, but also provides a unique window through which people can observe human behavior.
USD senior Tatum Gries expressed her thoughts on the paradox of pop culture’s categorization of high and low art.
“I read a lot, I listen to music all the time, I’ve logged over 400 films in my Letterbox; I appreciate art,” Gries shared. “But I’ve also seen four complete seasons of ‘Love Island’…Just because something’s popular does that mean it’s less good? ‘Love Island’ isn’t this amazing, deep story, but it’s real. I think it is pretty vulnerable to some extent to put yourself on national TV and be judged and picked apart and edited… I think there’s something really bold in doing that.”
USD senior and English major Elara Gibbons shared her personal relationship with the arts.
“I grew up creative writing a lot and I used to want to be an author, so definitely a lot of writing in my life as far as art,” Gibbons expressed. “I’m also on the internet a lot, so I play a lot of video games…and I consider video games art. I think we interact with art everyday in different ways.”
Gibbons shared examples of high and low art merging and evolving over time.
“[For] an example, Surrealism is a 20th century, avant-garde literary theory and art form,” Gibbons argued.
“I would say surrealism is 100% a high art. Then you have ‘dreamcore’ and ‘weirdcore’ which are internet aesthetics that are sort of low art versions of Surrealism. If you look at dreamcore or weirdcore you can see aspects of surrealism imitated through them.”
With the rise of technology and the internet, the convergence of high and low art is more tangible now than ever before. People have access to all forms of media and have the power to consume, recreate or study it to the fullest extent.
In his book “Literary Theory: A Short Introduction,” a required reading for many students in courses across the English department, author Johnathan Culler discusses the connection he sees between various cultural art forms and literary art. He suggests that cultural studies are often regarded as lower forms of art in comparison to forms such as literature.
“In theory, cultural studies is all-encompassing: Shakespeare and rap music, high culture and low, culture of the past and culture of the present,” Culler wrote. “But in practice, since meaning is based on difference, people do cultural studies as opposed to something else.”
Gries, an English major, shared her reaction to Culler’s explanation.
“I think I agree with it for the most part, especially about which one is held the highest,” Gries commented. “For me, it raises the question of ‘who gets to decide what’s considered high and low [art]?’ It can be slightly pretentious to consider something low art. Obviously there are things that are considered high art for a reason… I just don’t love the word low art. I think there needs to be some middle ground.”
Some critics online argue that high and low art often intersect and the lines between the two are defined by culture and time, and less so by binary descriptions.
Duraj discussed the intersection of the two forms she has witnessed from talking to her students in class.
“The first thing I think of is ‘The Odyssey,’” Duraj said. “As a film, it seems like most students saw that over the summer, at least when I asked. A lot fewer kept their hands up when it came to reading the poem. What’s exciting to me is that the popularity of the film brings that into the world of a generation that might not encounter it. It’s a way in which the popularized version of the narrative or text can expose people to a richness that they might have otherwise missed. I think that convergence is only good.”
Social definitions of high and low art will certainly continue to shift as culture evolves and time progresses. Its importance as the very framework of society reflects just how valuable art is to human beings, in all of its forms.





Join the conversation